29 May 2024

Remember Me? | Join | Recover
Click here to sign in via social networking

Dimmer - Album Review: Live At The Hollywood

09 Nov 2023 // A review by roger.bowie

Wow, not very often that we see alive album these days, an unusual beast, but that’s we have, a 14-track monster from Dimmer, recorded from last year’s sold-out trilogy at the Hollywood Avondale. Which, if you didn’t get to go last year, you can still see on December 2nd at the Powerstation, unless, like me, you are going instead to The War on Drugs.

Bugger, but thank God there’s a live album I can hear at home.

Shayne P Carter fell out of love with rock by the time Dimmer became a recording thing, and in 2001 released I Believe You Are A Star, a darker, electronic journey largely created at home using the new technologies and a drum machine. But in another reinventive moment, he then gorged on Thelonius Monk, and brought the impro of jazz back to the rock theatre, before completing the circle after a reunion tour with Straitjacket Fits. The subsequent two Dimmer albums reverted to a rockier standard before Shayne folded the band in 2012.

And so it came to pass that Shayne P Carter found guitar hero redemption supporting Don McGlashan, at least that’s how it sounded to me, before announcing a 20-year anniversary tour celebrating I Believe You Are A Star, which was subject to Covid delay until last year.

A brief history of time to provide context to the joy that for the most part prevailed Live At The Hollywood or probably did prevail if you were there and only marginally compromised by the distance between the actual and the recorded. Plus, the 14 songs have been selected from over the three night’s performances and do not reflect the setlist order, which I understand followed the album order and presumably threw in the songs from subsequent albums towards the end. So, this is a live record which sets out to create a new experience from the original one.

Which means you are Getting What You Give from the outset, a most un-Dimmer song from sophomore album You’ve Got to Hear The Music, but a fantastic opening track which almost puts a cabaret context to what follows, not unlike the way Marlon Williams opened at the Hollywood a few years back. Cool, jazz funk soul groove to set the scene. 

Drop You Off begins a seven-song extract from the Star album, and the sound is more familiar, dreamy and spare but the real drumming from Gary Sullivan is Miles Davis better, less electronica, more jazz-rock. I Believe You Are A Star (the song) is also better, with real bass from James Duncan, and stuttering psych guitar chords which brings lefty Shayne into the Jimi realm. 

Pendulum, Drift and Smoke. The sound intensifies. Exquisite harmonies from Louise Nicklin and Neive Strang. The sound of birdsong. Live At The Hollywood Aviary. All leading up to Seed, a 10 minute plus blockbuster of a Canadian drone grunge journey which crosses between Neil Young's Crazy Horse and an American Woman from Guess Who? 10 minute-plus songs these days risk getting labelled indulgent, but not in a live context, and certainly not this one.

You know what? During my preparation for this review, I pulled out the original album and played it, and I can’t help myself from saying, right now, this album is so much better. What’s worse, I now remember when I contemplated buying tickets for last year’s gig (postponed from the year before, when I did have one) and dipping into the 2001 version and going yeah, nah, don’t fancy this type of music anymore. What a bloody idiot. I should have trusted Don McGlashan’s judgement.

Ok, mea culpa over, let’s carry on. Under The Light continues the transformation from garage tools to big band arena and then we have a Scrapbook rendition from 2006’s There My Dear. The Doors meet the Cure with driving Hawkwind rhythms. Hold on to your head. The songs are getting longer as befits the build of a live gig, although the final two selections from Star, All The Way To Her and Evolution are short. The discordant intro to What’s A Few Tears To The Ocean, which is a beautiful title for a song, gives us a break from the relentless and a time to dream and sway (even at home). It’s a Searching Time from 2004 with questioning power chord permutations and a reminder that there are not one but two, maybe three guitar heroes in this band as well as Durham Fenwick on keys. 

And finally, the crystallization of all that has gone before, and is now presented in glorious vinyl on Crystalator records, as this remarkable record closes out, as it must do live, with the very first Dimmer recording, back in 1994: Crystalator, a rollicking ramshackle of unhinged guitar histrionics which is now staple Dimmer diet.

Shayne P Carter, I believe you are a star. Which will not Dimmer. 


About Dimmer

Dimmer was the name under which New Zealand musician Shayne P Carter (formerly of Straitjacket Fits, The DoubleHappys and Bored Games) recorded and played music from 1994. It began as an umbrella name for jam sessions and short-lived band line-ups, then home recordings, then an ensemble with various members and guests. This evolution led to more settled four-piece rock band (especially from 2006–10, when only the bassist changed). At least 41 musicians have been acknowledged as playing a part in Dimmer over 18 years, with Carter the only permanent fixture.

The last Dimmer recordings were made in 2009, with the band playing live shows through 2010. A short farewell tour announced the end of the band in 2012, and Carter began recording under his own name after that. Reformed and reformatted versions of Dimmer have occasionally played live shows, drawing on all four Dimmer albums, since 2018.

All four of Dimmer's albums were admired by critics, and all earned multiple New Zealand Music Award nominations. Non-album singles were released in 1995 and 1996, with debut album I Believe You Are A Star not following until 2001. In 2004 You've Got To Hear The Music was named New Zealand's Best Rock Album for the year, and Dimmer named Best Group. There My Dear saw Carter return to playing and recording with a live rock band in 2006, and return to the national album charts. Final album Degrees of Existence (2009) was recorded by the longest-lasting version of the band.

Visit the muzic.net.nz Profile for Dimmer


Live At The Hollywood
Year: 2023
Type: Album
Degrees Of Existence
Year: 2009
Type: Album
There My Dear
Year: 2006
Type: Album
It All Looks The Same At Night
Year: 2006
Type: Album
You've Got To Hear The Music
Year: 2004
Type: Album
I Believe You Are A Star
Year: 2001
Type: Album
Year: 1995
Type: EP

Other Reviews By roger.bowie

Album Review: Subset BC
16 Dec 2023 // by roger.bowie
Here’s an interesting little thing from Gisborne. A funky little band with three bass players.
Gig Review: The Best of Come Together @ The Civic Theatre, Auckland - 9/12/2023
12 Dec 2023 // by roger.bowie
Get your heads around this line-up:  The singers: Jon Toogood, (lead and backing vocals), Julia Deans (lead and backing vocals), Dianne Swann (lead and backing vocals and occasional guitar), Samuel Flynn Scott (vocals and guitar), James Milne (lead and backing vocals), Milan Borich (Mick vocals) The players: Jol Mulholland (guitars and vocals), Brett Adams (lead guitar and vocals), Mike Hall (bass), Matthias Jordan (keyboards), Alastair Deverick (drums), Finn Scholes (trumpet, clarinet and percussion), Nick Atkinson (sax and percussion).  Stopped spinning?
A Crude Mechanical - Album Review: Discourse
08 Dec 2023 // by roger.bowie
Shane Warbrooke doesn’t believe in lyrics, because of the risk of lyrics being hi-jacked and meanings bent to suit ideologies which he doesn’t like. Well, such ideologies which most of us don’t like, truth be known, but then again, Beethoven didn’t write lyrics, so the freedom of speech counter argument only goes so far.
Gig Review: The Phoenix Foundation @ Hollywood Avondale, Auckland - 24/11/2023
26 Nov 2023 // by roger.bowie
This is a first of many things. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen The Phoenix Foundation play live.
Velvet Arrow - Album Review: Songs of Solitude
17 Nov 2023 // by roger.bowie
A Song Of Hope & Fear would normally be a contradiction in terms unless darkness prevails and light shines through, which is an appropriate metaphor for the debut album from Whangarei’s Velvet Arrow and the opening song, with Dan Stenhouse’s husky voice helping us through the night against a ghostly horror wail from Hannah Jane. After all it’s just a song to help you through the night, just the words that speak, it’s not real.
Gig Review: Atomic: Women of Rock @ The Civic, Auckland - 11/11/2023
13 Nov 2023 // by roger.bowie
What a feast of nostalgia we’ve had from Liberty Stage (Simone Williams) these past few years, as New Zealand’s finest have Come Together to cover the classic albums which made the soundtracks of our youth. In addition to this, there have also been special tributes like Tami Neilson’s rock ‘n roll party with Dinah Lee, just last month.
Killergrams - EP Review: Lonely Nights In A Little Town
27 Oct 2023 // by roger.bowie
Someone walked out, and Tom Maxwell has lost his mind, in a gentle, acoustic way. Then his mind explodes in a cacophony of chaos, which might just be what it feels like, losing something that important.
D.C. Maxwell - Album Review: Lone Rider
24 Oct 2023 // by roger.bowie
I’ve Been Wrong, but every once in a while, someone comes along and knocks you out. Random violence is not what this is about, but D.
View All Articles By roger.bowie

NZ Top 10 Singles

    Tommy Richman
    Kendrick Lamar
    Billie Eilish
    Post Malone feat. Morgan Wallen
    Billie Eilish
    Sabrina Carpenter
    Billie Eilish
    Billie Eilish
View the Full NZ Top 40...
muzic.net.nz Logo
100% New Zealand Music
All content on this website is copyright to muzic.net.nz and other respective rights holders. Redistribution of any material presented here without permission is prohibited.
Report a ProblemReport A Problem