18 Feb 2019

Remember Me? | Join | Recover
Click here to sign in via social networking

Robby Thorne - Album Review: The White Thorn Track

13 Mar 2018 // A review by Peter-James Dries

There is a time and place for genre pedantry.

I get that categorising artists by genre is a way of qualifying if you will like music before trying it. Someone into The Feelers is probably going to have a hard time adjusting to Sinate.

Unfortunately, it can also be a way of excluding music based on an arbitrary, subjective title, reducing a body of work to a barbed word. This closed-mindedness, this “I only listen to pure Norwegian Black Metal” mentality can stop us from experiencing something that we enjoy outside of our usual sphere. I’m not casting no stones; I was guilty of it too.


No. I am not announcing my new meatless diet. I’m talking about Robby Thorne’s solo debut The White Thorn Track.

As the former-step-son of a travelling Country Western Singer, nothing sets my skin a crawling more than Country Music. So, to see the word Country in the same sentence as this album caused repressed flashbacks to reveal themselves. I felt the reluctance to get involved with this album.

But then I listened to it. 

This isn’t the Country I was nurtured to abhor.

One of my comrades, talked about the balance of simultaneous characteristics of Rock and Country when hereviewed this album’s titular single. Sure, there is a banjo layered over the guitar riff, but I argue that the Country influence has always been hidden in Rock, albeit in a more bluesy style than I was subjected to as a child.

Also, the former-step-son of a New Plymouth-style Bogan, there was also a portion of my life spent surrounded by Sabbath, Skynyrd, AkkaDakka, Led Zep, and Guns n’ Roses. Listening to Robby Thorne, I hear more of that influence than Willie, or Haggard, or Cyrus (the elder). No doubt an artefact of Thorne’s previous experience in White Thorne, Acid Rain and Puppeteer.

The title of the first track, A Tale of Thorns, Puppets & Acid Rain alludes to these earlier bands. It’s like a title page to this chapter of Thorne’s journey, a reference to the path he rode here on, and the experience that created the solo album we have before us.

Wait. OK. I just got to track four, The Wayfaring Stranger. There’s your Country. In the style of an old country standard, it’s a track that wouldn’t seem out of place if covered by… Well… The only modern Country I know is the Dixie Chicks… Maybe not them. But someone cool.

And then we’re back into the Rock. Solid Rock. Rock n’ Roll. Well written, catchy, perfectly structured. The banjo reappears periodically, fleshing out the sound, more than driving it. I don't feel that's a missed opportunity, because I think a lot of the appeal, for me at least, is hearing new Rock being produced in the style of old Rock.

I’ve seen a lot of… Interesting… music in my years perusing the New Zealand scene. You learn to distinguish the darlings of the Industry, you know, the ones the labels have thrown what little money is left in the arts into, from those at the coalface. Those home recording or working on their own dime.

You can’t distinguish with this album. It’s solid song-writing, a great performance, with seamless recording and mixing. Even if the songs were on the fly, or off the cuff, i.e. on the spot, I’d never know. This is the kind of album that should be paraded across all mediums, not some EDM douchebag standing on stage with a laptop, FL Studio, and an expensive music video.

Ok. Robby Thorne may not be revolutionary in his mix of Country and Rock, but he’s on the right track. I don't know if anyone has heard a banjo since Deliverance... But as a whole package, the album does its job, that is to say highlighting the talent of Thorne, and introducing us to his voice and vision. Tattoos, Beards, and Cowboy Boots. And the album does that job well. It deserves a greater listenership than this country can likely offer.

Today’s lesson: never trust the label. Unless it’s medication. You should probably trust that label.

You can find the White Thorn Track on iTunes and Spotify, and for those, like me, that grew up in a world when Rock, like real Rock, was on commercial television and radio, I recommend you do.

★★★★★ (5 stars)

Review written by Peter-James Dries


About Robby Thorne

Robby Thorne is New Zealand's latest solo artist combining Country themes, life & stylings to hard rock heritage born from the mind of Rob Sadd (Puppeteer).

Rob Sadd was born in Auckland NZ but spent his formative growing up years in the country Western Bay's suburb of Whakamarama about 30mins out of Tauranga. He began playing live right from the first moment of picking up an electric guitar "My first guitar was purchased the day after I made my first band, at that stage I hadn't played more than a chord".

At 15, Whitethorne was born, a punk band made up of 3 local boys, this project grew to become blues rock band Acid Rain as the musician's grew in age, ability, taste & influence and established their own sound, the sound that Robby Thorne has now has evolved further into his current solo sound.

Visit the muzic.net.nz Profile for Robby Thorne


The White Thorn Track
Year: 2018
Type: Album

Other Reviews By Peter-James Dries

EP Review: Feildings Best Dancers
12 Dec 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
In the words of your mum, Feildings Best Dancers is short, hard, and over far too soon. But she also said Thistle Highland Dancers were the best dancers in Feilding, so what does she know.
Craig Payne - Album Review: Good News
05 Nov 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
Come one, come all. Roll up and step inside the time machine of Payne.
Otium - EP Review: You
03 Oct 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
I’m usually reluctant to go too deep into music that on the surface seems shallow, or popular. Reading that this was reggae/funk hybrid band that sung on love initially made me shrivel.
Social Shun - Album Review: Somewhere Between Hate and Muffins
24 Sep 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
Somewhere Between Hate and Muffins: An experiment-like review for an experimental album. Observations Muffins: Warm.
Aaron Carpenter and The Revelators - EP Review: Roll with the Punches
20 Aug 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
The last bastions of real music in a world that celebrates mediocrity are the minnows swimming against the current of the mainstream.   What is the mainstream nowadays?
Brendan Pyper - Single Review: No Strings Attached
07 Jul 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
I think we have this decade’s Daniel Bedingfield on our hands. Diversifying his portfolio, The Latest Fallout’s Brendan Pyper has just released his debut single, in the process seemingly leaving his Pop Rock ways behind.
Tess Goodwin - Single Review: Grace
07 Jul 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
In this world of instant gratification, something can be said about a song that can make you feel, even if that feeling is longing. Longing, usually a feeling with negative connotations, is something you miss out on when you can binge watch an entire show or listen to a musician’s whole discography.
Emily Fairlight - Album Review: Mother of Gloom
03 May 2018 // by Peter-James Dries
Autumn at dusk. Sitting in a bay window, knees to chin, wrapped in sweatered arms.
View All Articles By Peter-James Dries

NZ Top 10 Singles

  • 7 RINGS
    Ariana Grande
    Ariana Grande
    Billie Eilish
  • WOW.
    Post Malone
    Post Malone And Swae Lee
    Ariana Grande
    Ava Max
    Lady Gaga And Bradley Cooper
    Sam Smith And Normani
View the Full NZ Top 40...
muzic.net.nz Logo
100% New Zealand Music
All content on this website is copyright to muzic.net.nz and other respective rights holders. Redistribution of any material presented here without permission is prohibited.
Report a ProblemReport A Problem